A posthumous collection of odds and ends, this actually holds considerable appeal for anyone who likes their pair of fully realized albums. The 12 songs include a few studio outtakes, a few solo turns by
Mimi on compositions written by
Richard but incompletely recorded at the time of his death, a couple performances from the 1965 Newport Folk Festival, and a couple of
Joan Baez tracks from sessions for an aborted album
Richard was producing with her. These leftovers are generally up to the standard of the two "real" albums, especially "The Quiet Joys of Brotherhood" (covered by
Fairport Convention) and "Morgan the Pirate" (a farewell to
Bob Dylan, according to the sketchy liner notes). The two cuts by
Baez (which
Richard wrote or co-wrote), especially the compellingly melancholy "All The World Has Gone By," are excellent, leading one to wonder if the projected album they came from would have been one of
Baez's best if it had been completed. These may be leftovers, but it's a worthwhile collection nonetheless.
–
Richie Unterberger, Rovi